Solid construction
Real wood, metal frames, dovetail joints. It holds value and survives a move. Press-board breaks down fast, and buyers can usually tell from the listing photos.
If you can't realistically resell it for at least three times what you're about to pay, walk away. That gap is what covers fees, your time, and the pieces that don't sell.
Filter completed/sold listings for the exact item, not what other hopeful sellers are asking for it.
Upholstery and finish are fixable. Cracked joints, bent frames, and water-soaked wood usually aren't worth it.
The item, the doorway, the stairwell, the elevator if there is one. Before you hand over cash, not after.
Resale estimate minus fees, minus fix costs, minus your time. Compare that number to the asking price, not your gut.
No exceptions for "it's such a good deal." That's exactly the deal that doesn't work out.
I've flipped maybe two dozen pieces over the last few years, mostly on weekends, mostly out of a borrowed truck. The ones that made money and the ones that didn't come down to the same five minutes of math, done either before I paid or never.
Not all sources are created equal. The lower your cost basis, the more room you have for things to go sideways and still come out ahead. Ranked by typical markup over cost.
In order of what to check first when you're standing in front of a piece deciding whether it's worth your time.
Real wood, metal frames, dovetail joints. It holds value and survives a move. Press-board breaks down fast, and buyers can usually tell from the listing photos.
A maker's stamp, a labeled drawer, a signature underneath. A quick search can turn a $40 guess into a $400 piece. Always check before you price it.
Stains, dated hardware, and scuffed finish are cheap fixes. Water damage, structural cracks, and bent frames usually cost more in labor than the piece is worth.
The usual ways a good deal on paper turns into a piece sitting in your garage for two months.